The Cask of Amontillado! - words | Study Guides and Book Summaries
relationship between the success that Poe's Tales had in the market and to .. his wife, in “The Cask of Amontillado” Montresor kills his friend Fortunato, in “The. In comparison to Montresor, Fortunato's character is flat and static through the story. . enemy is symbolic of the relationship between Montresor and Fortunato. Edgar Allen Poe's "The Cask of Amontillado" is all about who has power over who (at least in Montresor's mind, that is). The thousand injuries of Fortunato I had borne as I best could, but when he ventured upon insult I vowed revenge. Explain the irony in the brief relationship.
Many critics seem hesitant to conjecture about the nature of the insult, while others maintain diverse opinions about it. Freemasonry, though not a religion, embraces religious elements Lewissome of which conflict with Catholicism. John Freehafer disputes this theory: While acknowledging the general religious-politico foundation of the murder motive, Shannon Burns asserts: In the nature of Italian revenge his injury is specific: It need not be precisely defined, beyond those terms.
Other Interpretations Other critics have devised various murder motives for Montresor that are weak or flawed in logic. She claims that Montresor only speaks of revenge to direct attention away from his perverse need to destroy a friend For example, Montresor gives Fortunato repeated chances to escape his fate and shows him the murder weapon, as gentlemanly revenge requires, but Fortunato is not wise hence, not gentlemanly enough to recognize the hints.
That Montresor is evaluating Fortunato is unlikely; no gentleman could pass such tests particularly if intoxicated. A third critic, James W. However, Poe provides no indication that these clever dualities are hallucinations, or that they stem from inner conflict.
They could merely be symbols of an ironic, simultaneous resemblance and divergence between the men, perhaps intended to highlight their joint membership in a brotherhood that transcends religious-politico differences: Works Cited Burns, Shannon.
The irony Poe skillfully added is dominant from the introduction of the characters to the bone chilling end. Being told in first person by Montresor, Poe thrusts the reader into a believable tale, though the narrator may not be reliable or trusted solely because of his actions. They put cloaks on as they walk to the vaults.
Though no dates are mentioned, there is no doubt the confession takes place fifty years after the event.
The Cask of Amontillado | bornholm-sommerhus.info
Poe develops the characters instantly in the story. Montresor is the antagonist. He is round and static throughout the development of the story. He is arrogant and does not feel sorry for his actions; in contrast, he is extremely satisfied with what he has done.
The Cask of Amontillado
The reader gets the sense that Montresor simply applies what he believes is justice upon Fortunato. Fortunato is the protagonist, and never sees what is coming until the very end of the story. Since the story is told by Montresor, the reader learns his attitude, and can feel a good sense of who he is in this moment of his life as he commits this act.
Fortunato is then thrust into the trickery Montresor has premeditated when he tells Fortunato about a bottle of wine and though they are both wine connoisseurs, invites Fortunato to show off his expertise. Montresor has truly thought of everything ahead of time to ensure success. As the two go into the caverns of the cellar, the damp air makes Fortunato cough. When Montresor knowingly agrees, they continue their journey deeper into the catacombs.
When Montresor speaks it to Fortunato, he is gnorant of what it means, but too proud to ask. Montresor also talks of his family arms; a serpent being stepped on by a boot, its fangs in the boot.
Revenge in Edgan Allan Poe`s "The Cask of Amontillado"
In the climax of the story, Montresor again implores Fortunato to leave with him as they near the end of the vault, and once again, he declines as he finds the Amontillado and is sure he will now prove his substantial worth as a connoisseur.
Montresor then fastens him onto the floor of the vault. Fortunato becomes frightened and sobers at first.